Sheep’s Milk Yogurt with Almond-Pistachio Olive Oil Granola

Olive oil granola with almonds and pistachios

When I first moved to San Francisco, I lived in a very fun, tasty neighborhood about a block away from the corner of Haight and Ashbury nearby one of the San Francisco Boulangerie bakeries. I would always order some sort of croissant or toasted baguette to accompany my cappuccino and could not fathom what possessed the weirdos who ordered the granola, fruit, and yogurt when there were such divine breakfast pastries.

Fast forward a couple of years and I was having breakfast there with my husband and son who had only been eating solids for a few months. Since yogurt was one of his favorite foods (and still is at almost five years old) I added one of the yogurt and granola bowls to our order. I only felt a tad bit guilty about how many bites I stole from him. It would have hurt his poor little stomach to have finished it alone, right?

Pistachios, almonds, and pumpkin seeds

My grandparents always seemed to have a stash of granola around when I was growing up, but they usually ate it with milk and blueberries, not yogurt. When I was twenty-one, I traveled through Greece with my (then boyfriend) husband and had one of the Cyclades islands mainstays–strained yogurt with honeydew melon, apricots, walnuts, and honey. Over the years I have tinkered with various favorite granolas, but in the last year or so I have found the most synergistic of marriages in an olive oil granola with fresh fruit (melon and some stonefruit are ideal) and sheep’s milk yogurt.

Cardamom pods

Every few weeks I make a batch of my favorite granola. One of the latest cues for whipping up this easy-peasy, delicious granola tends to be when Rebecca from Garden Variety Cheese is selling her other-earthly fresh sheep milk yogurt. For those of you who think yogurt and granola is for health nuts, uh, cover your eyes for the next part. Sheep’s milk yogurt has well over twice as much fat as cow’s milk and results in a creamy, sinfully tasty yogurt that resembles strained Greek yogurt. It also has a recognizably sheep-milk flavor and tang–much like a sheep’s milk cheese–that blends incredibly with the sweet granola and fruit.

Tastiest granola ever

As with any granola, this one is infinitely flexible for omissions and additions. I change it almost every time. Sometimes I do not feel like the cardamom, but rather a little star anise or a leftover vanilla bean pod. Other times, I add hazelnuts and almonds instead of the nuts and seeds below. The only thing I advise you not to alter too much is the proportion of the liquids. You need them to make things properly adhere. Finally, when the granola finally comes out of the oven and you are dying to taste it, RESIST! Do not stir it or touch it whatsoever.

Messy granola pans with carmelized maple syrup and brown sugar

What you will regret in having to soak your pans to wash them you will pat yourself on the back for in having perfect crunchy clumps of granola, not just tiny little crumbly pieces because you impatiently stirred the hot granola upon removing it from the oven.

Sheep’s Milk Yogurt with Pistachio-Almond Olive Oil Granola

Sheep’s Milk Yogurt with Pistachio-Almond Olive Oil Granola

(adapted from this recipe)

3 cups multigrain oats (such as oats, barley, rye, quinoa, etc.)

3/4-1 cup raw pistachios

3/4-1 cup raw slivered almonds

1/2-3/4 cup raw pumpkin seeds (also called pepitas)

1 cup coconut chips (natural food stores, Whole Foods, etc. sell these)

3/4 cup real maple syrup

1/2 cup extra virgin olive oil

1/2 cup packed light brown sugar

1 1/2 teaspoon sea salt or 1 teaspoon kosher salt

1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon

1/4 teaspoon ground cardamom (optional)

1/4 teaspoon ground star anise (optional)

discarded empty vanilla bean pod (if you have one lying around)

Preheat the oven to 350F degrees. Combine everything in a large bowl and mix well. If using the vanilla pod, let everything sit for five minutes, stir again, and then cook. Spread everything out onto a rimmed cookie sheet and cook for 35 to 45 minutes, stirring every 14 minutes or so until it is a golden color and fragrant like cookies. Do not stir after you take the granola out of the oven. Wait until it has completely cooled before breaking the granola out of the pan.

This entry was posted in Almonds, Breakfast, Nuts, Pistachios, Vegan, Whole Grains and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Sheep’s Milk Yogurt with Almond-Pistachio Olive Oil Granola

  1. Reva says:

    Delicious! Just made a batch and love the flavor and the texture and the sheer joyful crunch of it… 2 questions…. How do you recommend storing for a week or so? And have you tried lightly oiling your pan to ease removal of cooled granola? Or used a silpat mat? OK, that’s more like 3 questions….

  2. cuocaciccia says:

    Thanks Reva. I store leftovers in an airtight container after they have cooled. The silpat mat, or parchment is a great idea, but oiling the pan probably would not work as well only because one stirs the granola enough that I think it would not matter to prevent sticking. Let me know how it works for you. To be honest, so long as I soak the pan for five minutes, it all comes right off so it has not bothered me too much.

  3. Bernard J says:

    I love your recipes (even more your descriptions of your recipes)! Why exactly do you caution your readers to resist the urge to sample when just out of the oven?

  4. reva says:

    Hi — I’ve really enjoyed this recipe since seeing it here last year … I just saw a version of it in Melissa Clark’s cookbook….and now a variation is on ( ). Gotta say that baking this “granola crack” on a parchment paper-lined sheet has made life a lot less stressful during cleanup time… 🙂 And I love the way your recipe has encouraged me to vary the nuts and grains that I use. I’ve made an extra snappy/crunchy version a few times with pearl barley & quinoa mixed in with rolled oats.

  5. Connie says:

    Ours just cooled enough to eat – – and it’s disappearing fast. Thank you for once again making me look good! I added some millet & some chia seeds that happened to be in the freezer. Looks like with your magic for the proportions & the other ingredients a vast variety of grains, ssed & nuts can be used. Thanks, again & the happiest of holidays to you and yours.

  6. Dear Cuoca,
    I made a batch of your delicious granola this morning and, um… I have good news and bad. The good news: I managed not to dig into the finished product until it was cool, so I succeeded in salvaging big chunks when I finally broke it up. The bad news…: I then proceeded to nibble on it for the rest of the day! In truth, I’m not complaining; if that’s the bad news for the day, I’m thankful. : )

    Thank YOU, as always, for such happy-making ideas, photos, and recipes. I love every new post and — obviously — keep returning to the old.

    Keep ’em coming!

Leave a Reply to Connie Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s